Best Neutral Eyeshadow Palettes

7 of the Best Neutral Eyeshadow Palettes for the Subtly Sexy Gaze that You can Wear Daily

Beauty trends may come and go but neutral eye makeup is forever. Sure, they’re quite big right now, especially when the no-makeup makeup look made waves a couple of years back. However, it’s safe to say that the best neutral eyeshadow palettes have always been in use by the general populace.

And why not when they’re practically the most versatile cosmetic products for your eyes? It’s even entirely possible that there are people who don’t own any other palette than their neutral one and are still capable of whipping up various looks. While you don’t have to go to such lengths, but it should reassure you that you won’t have to stick with just one look.

Just how versatile can these products be? For starters, they’re perfect for everyday looks. They’re very easy to use to enhance your features and bring out your eyes. They’ll also make you look fresh which is always a great thing. With more sophisticated techniques, however, it can also take your daytime looks up a notch without going overboard.

Add in some texture, shimmer, or even a dramatic cat eye and you can already transform your neutral eyes to something bolder and great for night time. This makes it an amazing choice for those who don’t like wearing a lot of color on their face.

Unfortunately, not all neutral eyeshadow palettes are created equally. Some will not even spread nicely on your lids or have enough pigmentation to look visible. This is why it’s important to find the right product if you want to take advantage of what these cosmetics have to offer.

To help you with that, we’ve rounded up some of the most useful tips and highly-recommended products that can help you find the perfect nude palette for you. Check them out below.

Our Top Rated Neutral Eyeshadow Palette

  • arrow-right
    Created with ingredients of the highest quality
  • arrow-right
    Most updated ultra-micronized, luxuriously pigmented waterproof eyeshadow cream formula
  • arrow-right
    Travel friendly case with magnetic lid 

Best Neutral Eyeshadow Palettes on the Market


  • Highly pigmented and easy to apply
  • Versatile colors
  • Very affordable


  • Tin packaging is quite durable
  • Beautiful warm colors
  • Applicators included


  • Compact enough for your makeup bag
  • Wide range of colors
  • Highly pigmented and easy to work with

Buying Guide: Top Tips in Choosing a Neutral Eye Palette

Neutral eye palettes may have nearly identical shades inside but it doesn’t mean that you can just pick up the first product you come across with. There are lots of subtleties that make a product work so if you want your makeup to give you the best results, you should take note of the following:

Choose the shades according to your skin coloring.

When it comes to choosing a color to wear on your skin, it’s always important to take your undertones into consideration. This small detail can make or break your look, so it’s crucial to keep this in mind.

So if you have a yellow or gold undertone, it’s ideal to opt for warmer shades. Look for palettes with reddish hues for the best results. For those with cool undertones, look for those with pinkish hues. If you have neutral undertones, then both can work well for you.

The best thing about these products is that they’re often labeled as warm or cool-toned eye palettes. This can make your search easier.

Aside from your undertones, your actual skin color can also be an important consideration when shopping for the best nude eyeshadow. The wrong pick might not show up on your skin, wash you out, or make you look sickly.

For example, if you have light skin, avoid going for the beige hues that are too close to your skin color. They might not show up on your skin or make it look ghastly. Warm hues with pink undertones are recommended by experts, however.

Olive skinned beauties could opt for cool toned hues, however. Light taupes and greyish beige shades will create an impact on your look.

The best neutral eyeshadow palette for dark skin, on the other hand, should contain light browns and golden red undertones. If they have some sheen to it, the better options they’ll be. These shades will contrast nicely with your skin and highlight its coloring.

Only opt for highly pigmented options.

An eye palette may have the most gorgeous shades and packaging but if they’re not highly pigmented, skip them. If they’re not pigmented enough, the colors won’t show up anyways, so why bother? You’ll only end up using and wasting a lot of the product in such cases when there are perfectly good alternatives out there.

A highly pigmented eye palette will make application simpler. They will also be easier to blend, giving you gorgeous results without struggling with the process.

Always take your eye color in consideration.

The great eyeshadow palettes for brown eyes might not be the exact same product for those with blue eyes. This is why you should also consider your eye color when shopping for eye makeup. Even if nude palettes are quite versatile, there will still be quite a few hues that will bring out the color of your eyes so they’re better picks than others.

How do you choose? Here’s a quick rundown of the recommended shades for different eye colors:

Brown: navy, indigo, purple, and cobalt blue tones

Blue: peach, copper, and orange tones

Green: berry, purple, and wine tones

Mattes and shimmers are all a matter of preference.

You always have an option between mattes, shimmers, and even metallics when it comes to eyeshadow colors. And even the best neutral palettes also come in these varieties so you might feel a bit confused which one to go for.

In all honesty, it’s entirely up to you which one to opt for. But as versatility is something a lot of people want in the best nude eyeshadow palette, you might want to look for something with an assortment of types and textures. If it contains both mattes and shimmers, then you won’t need another palette anymore. Your pick will already allow you to create natural and extravagant looks with ease.

Read reviews.

To know exactly how a product performs, you can always turn to reviews. They’re particularly useful for makeup products since you can learn essential details like how pigmented it is, how easy it applies on the skin, and how long does it last. Some reviewers will also add other useful details about the product so you can be sure to learn a lot of things that can help you decide whether a product is worth your money before spending any.

Neutral Eyeshadow Palette Reviews

After learning what to look for and consider while shopping for a great eye palette, it’s natural to want to know which products worked for a lot of people. So to help you with that, here are seven neutral eyeshadow palette reviews that can get you acquainted with the most popular items today:

Starting off this list is a nice starter kit for those who want to try spicing up their look with more subdued eye makeup. With the Lamora Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette in Matte, you can already have a wide range of color options at a low price. Its finish also makes it a highly versatile option, making this product a solid pick for a lot of people.

With 16 different warm eyeshadow colors, this item is already a steal at its price point. It shouldn’t really be a surprise since the brand is known for being an amazing budget beauty pick. While it might not have any shimmery shades, you can still use it for a wide range of looks. It’s great for everyday wear, though, so it’s also a very practical choice with its friendly price tag.

Speaking of eyeshadow colors, the hues included in this palette are perfect for just about everyone. Its earthy shades will look amazing on light skin with warm undertones. Their range will also suit all eye colors so you don’t have to fuss too much in finding a good match for your orbs.

It can also be deemed as the best neutral matte eyeshadow palette as all of its colors are completely matte. Such palettes are quite hard to find, so this also makes this product worth looking into.s a great draw to this product as well.

As for its quality, there’s also nothing to worry about. A lot of people compare it to more expensive brands, so that’s a really good sign. It’s highly pigmented and goes on smoothly so it’s easy to work with. Some are actually surprised at how nice the quality is given the price, so it can really prove to be a great choice for everyone.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Highly pigmented and easy to apply
  • check
    Versatile colors
  • check
    Very affordable

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Packaging might not withstand regular transport
  • exclamation-triangle
    Contacts talc which is a common irritant for sensitive skin

In need of a product that you can take along with you for regular touch-ups? The BYS 12 Shade Matte Eyeshadow Palette Tin Collection can be a solid option. This item is one of the many top-rated neutral eyeshadow palettes for the budget-conscious, so it’s definitely worth looking into.

Featuring 12 warm matte eyeshadow colors, this eye palette will also appeal to a lot of users. It will suit various skin tones and eye colors so there’s a good chance that it can also work for you.

But what really makes it worth your while is its portability. It also comes with a mirror that spans the entire length of the palette case so you can easily use it during makeup applications. It also comes with two applicators and a built-in holder so you can also opt to use it everywhere.

Highly pigmented, long-wearing, and very smooth, you won’t even be able to tell that this product is very affordable. This makes it a great choice for users of all skill levels and budgets.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Tin packaging is quite durable
  • check
    Beautiful warm colors
  • check
    Applicators included

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some reports of fallout so remember to dust off after application

For a handier and more compact version of the item mentioned above, you can check out the BYS On-the-Go Eyeshadow Palette. This can be the best neutral eyeshadow palette for those who are always on the road as it’s very portable and easy to take around with you.

This product is actually just a mini-version of the 12-shade mattes listed above. It only has 6 shades, though, so it’s way easier to lug around. As it also uses the same tin container as its bigger version so you can be sure that it’s suitable for traveling.

As it is just a smaller version of the 12-shade palette, you can also find similar colors in the On-the-Go palette. It still gets to offer a pretty good range of colors, though, so you can count on it to help you create different looks with ease.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Compact enough for your makeup bag
  • check
    Wide range of colors
  • check
    Highly pigmented and easy to work with

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some colors are dustier than others

In search of an eye palette that can work on your cool undertones? The Lamora Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup Matte + Shimmer is a product you should check out. With its equal parts of matte and shimmery colors, it can be everything you need to create all sorts of different looks with just one purchase.

Like the other Lamora eye palette mentioned above, this product also contains 16 colors. Seven of which are matte while nine are shimmery. This variety will let you create various looks, from casual to going out and special occasion looks, without having to reach for another palette.

This makes it an even more practical pick since it already offers everything you need at its very affordable price. As it also has great quality, it can definitely be a good choice for most shoppers. It’s highly pigmented and velvety smooth in texture so it will easily add color to your lids. You can also apply this product wet or dry to better achieve your desired results which makes it even more versatile.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Great pigment and smooth texture makes application fuss-free
  • check
    Beautiful colors and textures offer great versatility
  • check
    Suitable for creating a wide range of looks

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Box packaging might not be suitable for traveling

While most eyeshadow colors will work nicely with brown eyes, the best neutral eyeshadow palettes for brown eyes are still deemed as such because they can make the color of your orbs pop. One option for such products is the Lagure Eyeshadow Palette. Designed for creating different looks, it’s a nice option if you’re more partial with shimmery shades.

With its 10 shimmery and two matte nude colors, this product will let you upgrade your looks without going overboard. Its wide range of warm, earthy hues makes it a nice choice for a lot of wearers. However, if you have brown eyes, its purplish and bluish hues can easily bring out your eyes. As they also have some sheen to them, they can also highlight your peepers nicely.

This product goes smoothly on the skin and has a decent pigmentation so you can also get more than your money’s worth. Its packaging also contributes to this as it’s nicely and minimally designed. It even comes with a full-length mirror, a double-ended eyeshadow brush, and a brush holder so you can also take it with you everywhere.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Beautiful neutral colors
  • check
    Good packaging
  • check
    High quality at a low price

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some find the pigmentation to be a bit light but can be easily packed in

If you find eye palettes with so many different colors a bit overwhelming, then the Maybelline Makeup The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette, Chill Brunch Neutrals Eyeshadow might be a better fit for you. This product only has six colors that you can all wear in one go or choose to mix and match. They all work really well together, though, so you don’t have to worry about having to choose from so many different colors.

With its purple and wine tones, this palette will look great with green eyes. It can work with brown eyes, too, but those greens will really pop with the rich colors in this eye palette.

One of the most important things to note about this product, however, is that 4 out of 6 colors are shimmery. This makes it a great pick for night outs and special events, despite its name. As it’s also very compact and packaged in a sturdy housing, you can take it with you anywhere. This can help guarantee that your eye makeup will stay on point as the night wears on.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Portable thanks to its size and sturdy packaging
  • check
    Features six beautiful nude colors
  • check
    Nicely pigmented and blends in smoothly

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some colors are loosely packed so remember to dust off after application

For our last neutral eyeshadow palette review, let’s look at a nice dupe for one of the most popular nude eye palettes in the market today, the Cosprof 12 Colors Professional Eyeshadow Palette. Deemed by many as the best neutral eyeshadow palette for blue eyes, it might just be the very palette you’re looking for.

It’s no secret that the most famous eye palettes are quite pricey. They might also have nice colors but their pigmentation isn’t stellar, so why bother paying so much for one? With this product, you can get a wide range of similar peachy earth tones for much less and maybe even better performance so why not give it a shot?

Offering 12 shimmery colors with silky smooth texture, it can create various looks without any difficulty. You’ll also have enough color options to mix and match so you can create casual to formal looks with just a single product.

This item is also the most affordable pick on this list. So if you don’t want to spend so much on a palette for one reason or another, this can be a solid pick.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Fantastic price
  • check
    Beautiful colors that suit blue eyes nicely
  • check
    Goes on smoothly

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Does not have the exact shades as the high-end products

About the Author Samantha Brown

Growing up as a kid who played outside, Samantha enjoys an active lifestyle and emphasizes health as a key component to her life. She enjoys sharing her knowledge with others so that anybody can live a healthy life. On the weekends, you can find her hiking around Southern California!

Popular posts