Last Updated on
If you have sensitive eyes, you’ve probably thought of trying natural mascara. However, a lot of natural mascara brands might not be up to par as they lack the same chemicals as normal mascaras. These natural mascaras might often not be effective in holding your lashes’ curl. So which brands work? We’ve done the research for you in this guide.
[Overall Best Natural Mascara]
[BEST FOR THE MONEY]
[For Natural Looking AND Sensitive Lashes]
When it comes to using natural beauty products, there is an extensive list of benefits and reasons to switch from conventional brands.
The most obvious reason is that these products are toxin-free, dye-free, cruelty-free, paraben-free, gluten-free. They are also great for sensitive skin and eyes.
Products that are free of harmful chemicals and are made with all-natural ingredients produce less pollution during manufacture. Plus, they don’t contain any harmful chemical ingredients that lack the backing of skin and eye experts.
Some natural products utilize vitamins and minerals that have been proven to strengthen and promote growth in eyelashes. Meanwhile, some opt for a simplistic approach with strong pigments and sturdy formula.
Regulations of the ingredients contained in makeup products are still often lacking. So, companies don’t have to disclose all the information about their product if they want to omit something. This can be dangerous for your eyes’ health.
Natural and organic makeup products can be identified by the ingredients list with materials that you are likely familiar with and can pronounce. Look for mascara products that have a short list of ingredients.
The harmful chemicals that make up conventional name-brand mascara products have consequences to the safety and health of the user. Consequences that scientists and makeup producers aren’t even aware of yet.
This poses a risk for makeup users in changes to the biochemical makeup in cells, estrogen levels, and other ways that are currently still unknown.
With many mascara products to choose from, it’s hard to know which is best for a more natural and simplistic look.
The expressionist mascara from the brand W3ll People is a favourite in a lot of circles and has won awards for its sustainable production process, highly thoughtful formula, and amazing performance.
Another mascara from the brand HoneyBee Gardens has very strong reviews. These reviews state that it has a very natural, everyday look once applied.
The ingredients include avocado butter, aloe extract, and rosemary leaf extract, which are all very natural products that promote good skin health and lash strength.
For sensitive eyes and skin, you are looking for a formula with the shortest ingredients list, as well as ingredients that you can easily recognize.
The ingredients are listed from highest percentage to lowest percentage, so looking for a base ingredient of purified water or something similar is a great starting place.
Many products that are best for sensitive eyes will include avocado butter, aloe vera extract, beeswax, chamomile, vitamins B, and E, as well as various oil extracts and natural pigments.
All of these ingredients are completely natural, sustainable, and environmentally-friendly, as well as safe for both your skin and eyes.
The healthiest mascara formulas for lashes are usually those that include the most natural ingredients. Those with water as a base, and including safe oils, waxes, and other serums to make the mascara both effective as well as safe.
The pigment of naturally made mascara products is made from naturally occurring and common substances such as cinnamon, coffee, clay, and bark.
These colorants are effective and bold in pigment while also being environmentally-friendly and safe for application to the face.
There are so many more, but the natural oils that are in naturally made mascaras have extremely nourishing and moisturizing effects on the skin which improves the overall health of the lashes as well.
This all-natural organic mascara is a non-toxic mascara that’s perfect for the sensitive eye. The ingredients infused in this mascara promote eyelash growth and overall healthy lashes.
It doesn't contain any harmful chemicals, which prevents irritation and dryness. This makes it ideal for contact users, as well.
With this mascara, you can choose to do a natural look with just a single coat, or apply a few for darker, more intense lashes.
This natural mascara does an awesome job of volumizing, lengthening, and curling your lashes. All without creating any clumps or flaking in the process- no matter the amount you decide to apply.
The All Natural Organic Mascara is also long-lasting and sweatproof, making it perfect if you are very active throughout the day. This mineral mascara is paraben free and vegan, making it safe, moisturizing and gentle on the eyes.
If you have had bad luck with drugstore mascaras or you struggle to find a mascara that doesn’t irritate your eyes, this is a product that is worth checking out.
We all know an eye look is never complete without beautiful, long lashes. But the last thing you want is to end up with a flakey mess that dries out your eyes all day long.
So, go all-natural with the Maybelline New York Full n' Soft mascara. You can forget about irritation, dryness, and damage to your eyes and lashes.
It will dramatically enhance your eyelashes’ natural beauty while keeping them full and healthy.
The Maybelline New York Full ‘n Soft washable mascara is infused with Vitamin E, which thickens your eyelashes while still nourishing and moisturizing them.
The enriched formula of this mascara makes it easy to apply. It leaves your eyelashes with a soft and silky finish.
The best part about this mascara is its easy, fast removal. There is nothing more frustrating than taking 10 minutes before bed, scraping your mascara off, only to find that your eyelashes come off with it.
Using a gentle, hypoallergenic formula, this mascara is designed to protect and nourish even the most sensitive of eyes. It also contains natural waxes and clays that strengthen the lashes and promote eyelash growth.
The natural ingredients infused in this mascara give your eyes an overall natural finish while remaining highly pigmented. This leaves you with the gorgeous lashes you’ve been waiting for, without running the risk of irritation or damage.
This easy-on-the-eyes mascara also does not smudge or budge throughout the day, making it long lasting and reliable.
While this mascara is long-lasting, it is also extremely easy to remove and does not tug on your lashes in the process. You can easily apply it in the morning and remove it at night with your preferred soap or makeup remover.
If you like to change up your makeup look a lot, this mascara is a great option for you. Unlike many all natural mascaras on the market, this one comes in different colors making it very versatile.
Toullgo’s 4D Silk Fiber mascara is a completely natural and non-toxic mascara that gives you perfect, dramatic, bold lashes. Their formula is waterproof and can withstand tears, rain, sweat and a full day’s wear without smudging.
This mascara keeps your eyelashes long and thick by utilizing deep pigments without looking fake or over-the-top.
This mascara is not only designed to last you all day long, but it comes off easily at the end of the day. Simply use a makeup remover or cleanser and then follow up with a warm water rinse. Pat dry.
The formula will not irritate your eyes and can work for those who wear glasses or contact lenses without issues. Toullgo also offers a 100% guarantee that you will love their product, or you get your money back.
Because of the natural formula, it can take some time to get used to the application process. But with a little practice, it is easy to become a pro.
L’Oréal has been a household name for years and does not disappoint. Anyone who has ever seen a Japanese manga can immediately spot the large, doe-eyed look of all the characters.
For anyone who wants to capture that wide-eyed look, you know that it starts with the right mascara. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Miss Manga mascara aims to capture that look by providing oversized volume that will make your eyes look larger and create that manga-style look.
This mascara features a 360-degree Flexor brush for easy application. The wet formula makes your lashes look extremely long and dark. This gives you a look that makes your eyes pop and is ideal for cosplayers or those looking for a doe-eyed appearance.
Estee Lauder is another major name in makeup and is known for its high-quality formulas that are safe for everyone to use.
Their Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume mascara is no exception. It has been ophthalmologist-tested to be non-irritating and fragrance-free. So, there are no adverse side effects when using this product.
The application is designed to create long and thick lashes by featuring a brush with three different high volume fibers. This means every lash gets coated to create the best application and avoid clumping.
The glossy color of the mascara makes your eyes look wider. They’ll really stand out without looking too over-the-top or smothering your look. It naturally provides a curve as well as the volume you want, which creates a look similar to false lashes.
This allows you to not only save time and money on false lashes, but avoid irritation or risking losing lashes from improper application. Simply apply and enjoy the look of false lashes without having to do anything more than put on your mascara.
Loreal Paris is once again on the list with their Voluminous Original Volume Building Curved Brush mascara. The curved brush is used to lift and separate your lashes. It’s meant to to build them up and create the volume you want.
This also creates a much fuller look, to make your lashes bold and your eyes pop. Loreal’s Voluminous Original Volume Building mascara also allows you to get up to five times fuller lashes, making it ideal for those with thin lashes or those who want to forgo the false lashes.
If you don’t want the full “five times fuller lashes,” you can simply apply until you get the desired fullness, without having to worry about overdoing it. Like nail polish, using several thin layers is key.
Whether you are looking for the bold lashes for a night out or a more muted and natural look, Loreal provides you with several color options to help you get the look you want.
This means that you can get those long, full lashes without them appearing too over-the-top or too bold. It’s perfect for more casual events or work functions where you want to look professional.
Natural mascaras can be so vastly different in their ingredients as well as their intentions as beauty products. But many of them have your safety and health in mind.
Whether you want lengthening features, bold colors, or just a natural look, there are many great natural mascara options out there for you.
Hi, I'm Matthew, or Matt for short. I studied English and Journalism at University in Toronto, CA to pursue a career in writing. I've worked for several small blogs and a local newspaper before transitioning to Healthy Top 10s. I love writing about health to encourage people to live a more active life style.In my free time I love soccer and playing the guitar! Ask me about either one!