7 Best Mascara Reviews 2019 | Specialized Formulas for Gorgeous Lashes

    Last Updated on

    There are so many different brands and styles of mascara out there. It can be really hard to pick the best one. The best mascara does not necessarily have to come from an expensive brand – what really matters is what works best for you.

    [Overall Best Mascara]

    1. Mia Adora 3D Fiber Lash Mascara

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    • Volumizing look
    • Hypoallergenic product
    • Helps boost thin lashes

    Editor's Rating:

    4.1/5

    • Smudge-free and waterproof
    • All-day wear
    • Affordable

    [With Enhancing Serum that Promotes Growth]

    3. 3D Fiber Lash Mascara by Simply Naked Beauty

    Editor's Rating:

    4.3/5

    • Hypoallergenic formula
    • Naturally promotes lash growth
    • All-day wear

    Your mascara choice should depend on your eye sensitivity, how thick your natural lashes are, and what kind of look you are after.

    To help you make the best decision, we have put together a list of some of our favorite mascaras available right now, in 2019.

    There are some pros and cons to all of them, but any of these mascaras would be a great, affordable addition to your normal makeup routine.

    How to decide what is the best mascara to buy?

    If you’re trying to do a little digging on all the mascaras out there, prepare to be a little bit overwhelmed.

    There are far more factors than you might think to consider, including color, curl, volume, length, application, etc. But here are some starting points to help you narrow down some contenders to purchase.

    • Formula: Just like with the foods you eat, make sure you check the ingredients in your mascara. Avoid any allergens, and seek out a mild formula that won’t upset your eyes or skin, especially if you’re dealing with sensitive skin.
    • Wand: We mentioned the application above, but most people underestimate how important the wand is to the functionality of a mascara. Do a little research to find out which type of wand gives your lashes your desired look, and focus your search there.  
    • Lash Type: To help you determine which formula or wand works best, it’s important to know what type of lashes you actually have. It seems simple, but take a good look in the mirror and figure out whether your eyelashes are full or more sparse, shorter or longer, or straight versus curly. That way, you can seek out what qualities are most important to you.  

    What is the best smudge proof mascara?

    Coming home to look in the mirror and find dark smudgy circles under your eyes can be so frustrating, so cosmetics companies have done their best to fight that problem with smudge-proof mascaras.

    Now, this shouldn't be confused with waterproof mascaras. Some formulas can do both, but not all smudge-proof mascaras can be considered waterproof.

    Smudge-proof mascaras are designed to resist oil and humidity. There are great formulas out there, some from the drug store, and some a little pricier (see those natural, organic mascara tubes?).

    Some of our favorite smudge-proof mascaras include the Best 3D Fiber Lash Mascara by Simply Naked Beauty and Covergirl’s LashBlast Volume Mascara.

    What is the best water & sweat-proof mascara?

    To avoid that smudgy, oily look - there’s a couple of great mascaras out there you can try. First, bareMinerals Lash Domination.

    It will stay put until you take your make up remover to it at the end of the day. It’s waterproof as well, so it’s strong and long-lasting.  

    Another one of our favorites? 3D fiber mascara from Mia Adora uses a 3-step formula that has some serious staying power.

    It’s got great reviews from women who swear by that formula, and its thick, bristly wand. No flakes and no smudges.

    Just remember, for either of these mascaras, you’ll need an effective makeup remover (that’s still gentle on your skin of course.)

    Why does my mascara always smudge?

    One of the main culprits of the dreaded smudge is oil. So there are a few ways to combat this common beauty debacle. First, blot: blotting papers are inexpensive and can help you keep oil in check.

    We also recommend eye primer because, yes, even your eyelids can get oily. Otherwise, make sure to keep other products like moisturizers away from those eyes

    How can I make my mascara last longer?

    There are some successful hacks out there to improve the wear and longevity of your mascara.

    During use, try to limit the amount of air in the tube; that means limiting pumping the wand in and out and making sure to close tightly after each use.

    If your mascara is getting low or drying out, try adding a few drops of saline solution to revive the formula. Even eyedrops can work for this inexpensive hack.

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    This 3D fiber mascara from Mia Adora is one of our favorites for its awesome volumizing power. 

    Using natural, stimulating ingredients, it actually helps to boost thin, sparse lashes over time. It looks great while you are wearing it, plus it helps to improve the look of your bare lashes.

    Unlike a lot of other mascaras, this is a three-step process for longer, healthier eyelashes. That might be a downside for some people who like a quicker routine.

    But it doesn’t actually take too long: just apply the mascara, then the wet magnifying gel, and then the mascara again for stunning dramatic lashes.

    The best part? This volumizing mascara is paraben-free and safe to use with contacts. It will not hurt sensitive eyes. 

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Volumizing look
    • check
      Hypoallergenic product
    • check
      Helps boost thin lashes

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      3-step application takes longer

    Editor's Rating:

    4.1/5

    L’Oreal Paris’s 2-step mascara is a high-quality volumizing mascara in a double-sided tube. It gives you long, luxurious lashes that will last all day, and comes at a super affordable price.

    One side of the mascara tube is a nourishing eyelash primer, that will make your eyelashes appear thicker and longer before you apply the mascara.

    This is a smudge-proof, waterproof mascara that you can wear all day – it is guaranteed to last up to 16 hours, even in hot, humid conditions.

    You don’t have to worry about rubbing your eyes and accidentally smearing your mascara.

    Lashes can look up to 80% longer with this 2 step mascara than without it. Unfortunately, it is not formulated to support lash growth, but it is not harmful to your lashes either – it won't lead to breaking or thinner lashes over time, as some cheaper brands can.

    L’Oreal Paris is a well-trusted brand, and this is one of their more affordable quality mascaras. Not only does it come at a low price, but it will last a long time – as long as three to four months of everyday wear.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Smudge-free and waterproof
    • check
      All-day wear
    • check
      Affordable

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Not hypoallergenic

    Editor's Rating:

    4.3/5

    This fiber lash mascara is perfect for more sensitive eyes and promotes healthy lash growth, naturally. It is specially formulated to give you great lash volume while you are wearing it and to boost your natural lashes at the same time.

    Because it is a hypoallergenic mascara and has a gentle, natural formula, it is safe to use with sensitive eyes or while you are wearing contacts.

    Natural ingredients like beeswax and clays form a protective layer around your lashes, helping them to stay soft and strong and preventing breaking over time.

    Unlike other natural formulas, this mascara really does work as well as a less gentle brand. It will not clump or flake. Really, it lasts throughout the day without smudging.

    It also gives your lashes an amazing volume while you are wearing it.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Hypoallergenic formula
    • check
      Naturally promotes lash growth
    • check
      All-day wear

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Not completely waterproof

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    All Natural Organic Mascara is a type of mascara that is designed for eyelash growth, lengthening, and volume. 

    This voluminous mascara is described to last all day without clumping upon application, and will effectively curl, lengthen and thicken your eyelashes. The overall rating for the product on Amazon is 4/5 stars.

    It is not waterproof but it is meant to last all day long and be simple to remove at the end of the day. It also travels friendly so you can carry it around with you wherever you go.

    If you are worried your mascara will smudge, you will be able to fix it easily if you carry it with you.

    This mascara is non-toxic and perfect to use if you have sensitive eyes or wear contacts. It does not hold any harmful chemicals, is not tested on animals and has gentle and moisturizing qualities.

    The 100% natural ingredients in this mascara are completely safe and highly beneficial for eyelash growth.

    It is water resistant and sweatproof which is perfect for all-day use. The ingredients are vegan, gluten-free, and contain 85% organic ingredients.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Water resistant and sweatproof
    • check
      Made with organic ingredients such as Chamomile, Grapefruit, etc.
    • check
      Not harsh on sensitive eyes or skin

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      May cause allergic reactions

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    The bareMinerals Lash Domination mascara is a smudge-resistant mascara product that has many benefits rolled into one amazing product.  

    The ProTwist180 Wand that comes with this mascara is exclusive to bareMinerals. It’s spiraled to 180 degrees in order to reach every angle of your eyelashes. The overall rating of this product on Amazon is 4/5 stars.

    This mascara is a 10-in-1 volumizing, lengthening, thickening, separating, long-wearing, and smudge-resistant product that you can depend on to provide the best lash coverage and quality.

    It is not water-resistant, but it will last all day long if you can avoid getting water on your face. This product will work for you even if you have sensitive eyes and you will not feel the urge to scrub it off in the middle of the day.

    With the bareMinerals Lash Domination mascara, you can replicate the appearance of false lashes. All you need is a light and simple touch in order to apply this mascara effectively.

    Its ingredients are composed of nourishing minerals and quinoa protein complex to offer you the best volume possible.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Easy to apply
    • check
      Gives your lashes flawless definition
    • check
      No need to apply a large amount

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      May cause clumping

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    The Rimmel Scandaleyes Retroglam Mascara is a waterproof product that is hourglass brush shaped and will work to plump your lashes. 

    It will also fan your lashes up and out to give your lashes a bold volume. The overall rating for this product on Amazon is 4/5 stars.

    This product will coat your lashes individually to replicate the appearance of false eyelashes in one short, easy application without the concern of clumping.

    It will last all day, so you can avoid worrying about clumps or smudging. It will come off easily at the end of the day when you are ready to wash your makeup off.

    If you are searching to give your lashes a dramatic and voluminous look, this may be a good product for you to use.

    Each lash will be coated individually by this mascara to amplify the volume and length of your eyelashes.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Does not flake or clump
    • check
      Completely affordable
    • check
      Gives your lashes a fuller look
    • The brush works well for any eyelash size

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      The wand may not be the best quality

    Editor's Rating:

    4.0/5

    The DHC Mascara Perfect Pro Double Protection is a mascara product that prevents flaking, smudging, or smearing. It lasts all day long. 

    Upon application, your lashes will seem thicker and longer, giving you a more voluminous appearance. The overall rating of this product of Amazon is 4/5 stars.

    The precise mascara wand defines your lashes from root to tip and the mascara itself slides off with warm water and minimal pressure. This mascara is water resistant and designed with a tube technology formula that gives your lashes extra length.

    You can remove this mascara easily whenever you want to. The mascara wand works through your lashes thoroughly, no matter how thin or thick your eyelashes are.  It’ll give your lashes a dramatic effect.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Provides lengthening qualities with a single coat
    • check
      Healthier lashes
    • check
      Tiny wand prevents mascara from smudging onto your eyelids

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      May sometimes become dry

    Conclusion

    Even though mascara is a cosmetic staple for many women, not everyone puts a lot of time or effort into researching which of the dozens of styles and formulas might work best for them. Our guide will help you navigate the mascara jungle and go for the brands that truly work!

    About the Author Lindsey

    I developed a love for the outdoors, particularly enjoying gloomy days spent in the forests. Almost every Sunday, my dad would drive my mom, myself, and my older sister to go hiking for family time and escaping the "city" life. Because of this, you'll find me writing a lot about various health topics.Whenever I get the opportunity I also love to write about make-up, skin, and hair! I've been obsessed with it ever since middle school so be sure to check out these topics that I write about as well.

    2 Shares
    Tweet
    Share
    Pin2
    Share