if you have sensitive eyes, read our review to get yourself outstanding eye makeup

    5 Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes Reviews 2019 | All Natural Formulas With No Irritation

    Last Updated on

    If you struggle with sensitive eyes, you know how frustrating it can be to always be using products that cause irritation and discomfort. For that reason, finding the best mascara for sensitive eyes isn't something that you want; it's something that you need. Finding a mascara that doesn't irritate is the difference between feeling great in your makeup and being miserable while constantly feeling itchy and uncomfortable. Luckily there are a lot of options for makeup for sensitive eyes as this issue becomes more well-known and tended to.

    Top 3 Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes 

    [OVERALL BEST MASCARA FOR SENSITIVE EYES]

    1. Skin2Spirit Natural Mineral Mascara

    Editor's Rating:

    4.4/5

    • Made with natural ingredients
    • Won’t cause pain and irritation
    • Dual use eye-liner and mascara

    Editor's Rating:

    4.7/5

    • Dual function mascara and volumizer
    • Durable silicon brush head
    • Thick black formula

    [Best FOR DRAMATIC AND EXQUISITE LASHES]

    3. Vicious Teknology Waterproof Mascara

    Editor's Rating:

    4.3/5

    • Lengthening formula
    • Durable and waterproof
    • Hypoallergenic formula

    Is there a mascara for very sensitive eyes?

    If you’ve known nothing but traditional mascara your whole life, you might not know that there are other options out there. There are makeups out there for those with sensitive eyes. Generally, these makeups are going to have mild ingredients and not be so harsh on the skin and eyes.

    If you are starting the process of finding a good mascara for sensitive eyes, there are some things that you need to know before you start your search. You also probably have a lot of questions, which we are happy to provide our industry knowledge on.

    What is the best hypoallergenic mascara?

    Allergies and skin irritation can be incredibly unpleasant, and anyone who has had to deal with it can tell you that finding a mascara that doesn’t activate either of those is a bit of a challenge. Eyelids are a very sensitive area of the body and are easily affected by different chemicals and ingredients.

    Hypoallergenic mascara can vastly reduce the risk of allergens getting into your eyes and causing irritation and discomfort. A good hypoallergenic mascara will be free of harsh ingredients to minimize the chance of irritation. If you don’t like black mascara, you can check out other options here.

    Can I be allergic to my mascara?

    If you are frequently dealing with irritation and discomfort when wearing certain types of mascaras, it’s entirely possible that you are allergic to your mascara. Sometimes, that irritation is caused by something else. It can be caused by the use of harsh ingredients in the mascara getting into your eye.

    However, it never hurts to try out a hypoallergenic mascara for sensitive eyes to see if allergies were indeed the problem with the mascara that you were using. Since mascara is something you use often, you want to make sure that you aren’t allergic so that you can feel comfortable and safe when applying it. If you are having a hard time identifying what mascara to use or if you should be using mascara at all, you should check out this post for more info on the topic.

    Don’t get too close to the lashline

    Irritation and allergic reaction in the eye can be caused by a few different things. One of those factors is that you could be getting too close to the lashline when you are applying your mascara. Many mascaras don’t include ingredients that are exactly great for application on the surface of the eye. If you apply too close to the lashline, mascara could be getting into your eye and causing pain and irritation. Try backing off the lashline if you are experiencing these symptoms frequently after applying mascara.

    Remove mascara with care if you have sensitive eyes

    On the flip side of the application of mascara is the removal. Any time that you are removing or applying mascara, you are at an increased risk for it getting into your eye and causing problems. To avoid this, you can do two things.

    First, you can try to find a sensitive eyes mascara that doesn’t contain ingredients that are likely to irritate your eye in the first place. Next, you can be very gentle when removing the mascara. Many people tend to rub the mascara off which increases the chances that it will get into your eye and cause damage.

    Product Reviews

    Editor's Rating:

    4.4/5

    If you don’t have any particular or specific needs and just want the best overall mascara for sensitive eyes, this Skin2Spirit Natural Mineral mascara is a great option that we appreciate for its simplicity and quality. 

    This is the best natural mascara on the market. It helps to lengthen and thicken lashes while keeping out harmful and toxic chemicals. It’s tear-resistant and hypoallergenic, meaning you can rely on this mascara whether you have sensitive eyes or have allergies that cause discomfort.

    The non-toxic ingredients are appreciated by all of its users regardless of if they have any allergies or sensitivities.

    In addition to being great for your eye health, it’s also a very durable and long-lasting mascara that will look great all day. It can also be used as a liquid eye-liner, which adds a lot of value.

    If you tear up and get irritated every time that you put on mascara, you should try this non-toxic option that is made from natural ingredients. It's vegan, cruelty-free, and doesn't contain gluten, parabens, mercury, petroleum, or lead.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Made with natural ingredients
    • check
      Won’t cause pain and irritation
    • check
      Dual use eye-liner and mascara
    • Great for people with dry eyes

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      More expensive due to the quality of ingredients

    Editor's Rating:

    4.7/5

    For a good value and affordable price, you can get this 4D Silk Fiber Las by VieBeauti. We are confident that this is the best waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes. It stands up to rain, sweat, and tears and you can wear it all day without the concern of melting or irritation.

    It can help your lashes become bolder and lusher as well. VieBeauti uses an advanced formula called 4D Silk Fiber which helps to bring out your eyes and make your lashes look great with only one coat.

    The reason that we have named this as the best mascara for your money is that it also comes with a second bottle of fiber for more volume. 

    The value of this product is very high because of the amount of mascara that it offers and the dual functionality. The price of it is also quite affordable.

    Finally, this mascara is completely hypoallergenic and friendly to sensitive eyes. It doesn’t use harsh chemicals and won’t stir up trouble in your eyes when applying or removing it. Hypoallergenic mascara isn’t often this affordable, making this mascara a great value.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Dual function mascara and volumizer
    • check
      Durable silicon brush head
    • check
      Thick black formula
    • Hypoallergenic

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Doesn’t contain a lot of natural ingredients

    Editor's Rating:

    4.3/5

    If having full and dramatic lashes are a big priority for you, the Vicious Teknology Heavy Full Figure mascara is going to be a good option to consider. It makes your lashes look full and luscious while also catering to those who have eye and skin sensitivity.

    It has natural and hypoallergenic formulas to avoid irritation and allergic reactions, and it's made of non-toxic plant-based ingredients.

    All of these help to contribute to the making your lashes appear fuller and longer. The mascara is also packed with vitamin E to enhance the appearance. 

    You won’t have to worry about the mascara coming off during the day or in sweat, tears, or rain because it is waterproof and long-lasting. You can put this mascara on with full confidence that it won’t come off during the day or cause allergic reactions.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Lengthening formula
    • check
      Durable and waterproof
    • check
      Hypoallergenic formula

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Slightly more pricey due to quality and ingredients

    Editor's Rating:

    4.2/5

    Toullgo 4D Silk Fiber mascara is made to help improve the length and volume of your eyelashes. The 4D silk fiber formula increases and adds volume to your eyelashes. If you are going for a glamorous look while still avoiding irritation and sensitivity, this is an excellent option for you. 

    It’s waterproof and long-lasting. It will stay on your lashes through rain, tears, and sweat. It’s also resistant to smudging and flaking, which is a common problem for mascaras. When it comes time to clean, it’s easy and fast.

    You can wash it off easily with warm water or your makeup remover of choice. This mascara is specifically designed to stay on even if you have a very active lifestyle that involves a lot of moving, working out or travel. Taking the stress out of your day is one of the many things that it brings to the table. 

    It does all of this while using healthy ingredients. It doesn’t use oil or dirty ingredients that will damage your lashes and skin. While it doesn't have any specific harmful chemicals, it's also not the most naturally-made mascara out there.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Long-lasting and durable
    • check
      Makes lashes look lush and elegant
    • check
      Non-toxic ingredients

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Not hypoallergenic

    Editor's Rating:

    4.4/5

    AsaVea has a great reputation in the cosmetics industry for making quality and healthy products, and that doesn't stop with the Natural 4D Silk Fiber mascara that they carry. 4D Silk Fiber is a formula used by many brands, and it is excellent for making lashes appear more healthy, long, and thick. 

    If you struggle with mascara that doesn't do your eyelashes any favors with how it looks or how durable it is, this is a good option for you. It creates instant volume and length with the 4 D Silk Fiber.

    The reason that it looks so distinguished is because of the dark pigments that give your lashes that extra pop.

    It stays in place all day, so nothing to worry about there. If there is a weakness to this mascara, it certainly isn’t the durability. It’s easy to put on and take off, so there is less risk of getting it in your eye and causing irritation or reactions.

    Things We Liked

    • check
      Waterproof and durable
    • check
      Smooth application and easy removal
    • check
      Gentle & safe formula
    • High quality from a reputable brand

    Things We Didn't Like

    • exclamation-triangle
      Brush might break while applying

    About the Author Lindsey

    I developed a love for the outdoors, particularly enjoying gloomy days spent in the forests. Almost every Sunday, my dad would drive my mom, myself, and my older sister to go hiking for family time and escaping the "city" life. Because of this, you'll find me writing a lot about various health topics.Whenever I get the opportunity I also love to write about make-up, skin, and hair! I've been obsessed with it ever since middle school so be sure to check out these topics that I write about as well.

    1 Shares
    Tweet
    Share
    Pin1
    Share