make your eyes more beautiful with one of the best eyeliners

7 Best Eyeliners for Oily Lids | Reviews to Make Your Eyes POP

A lot of makeup-wearers will agree that the struggle is so real if you have oily eyelids. It makes oily skin seem inconsequential as it can be a bigger hassle to deal with oily eyelids. Even if your eyelids make up a very small portion of your face, you’ll still need to find the best eyeliners for oily lids if you want the best results.

Here are the Best Eyeliners that will Last on Oily Lids:

4.3/5

  • Easy to work with
  • Lasts all day
  • Creates highly versatile looks

4.2/5

  • Formulated with moisturizing ingredients
  • Self-sharpening
  • Has some sparkle

4.1/5

  • Gentle and cruelty-free formulation
  • Highly pigmented
  • Waterproof and guaranteed long-lasting wear

Why is getting a quality eye shadow so important?? Well, for one, it’s harder to touch up eye makeup. Executing the perfect cat-eye is such a feat for some folks that they’re often immortalized in selfies. Some even take it as a good sign that their day will be good because their flicks look like twins.

All of these efforts tend to go to waste easily, though, if you have oily lids and a sub-par eyeliner product. Your natural oils can break down the formula and cause it to smudge, slide off, and even disappear completely. Having to retouch these lines can be a nightmare since there’s a high chance that you’ll only ruin it. Besides, if your lids are already oily, there’s also a good chance that the product won’t adhere nicely to your skin.

The most excellent solution to such woes is to just find the best eyeliners for oily lids. These products can promise great quality and long-lasting wear, so even if you have oily eyelids, they will stay in place. There’s also a good chance that you won’t have to touch up your eyeliner by midday with the right product.

How do you find the right eyeliner that won’t budge on your oily eyelids? Here are a few tips and even product suggestions that you might find helpful.

What to Look for in the Best Eyeliners for Oily Lids

Contrary to popular belief, the best eyeliners for oily lids are not the easiest cosmetic products to get. They are not made equally and definitely not all of them will work on oily eyelids. This makes it crucial for you to choose carefully if you want the best results.

But how do you find the right products that will suit your needs and requirements? Here are some tips that you might find useful:

Get to know the formulas available to you.

One of the first things you need to know when shopping for the right eyeliner for you is the fact that these products come in different varieties. While these products are formulated to last all day, not all of them gets the job done. Some types, however, are more likely to last longer on oily skin, so you have to check them out.

try the best eyeliners for oily lids till you find the one that works for you

For example, experts believe that gel-based formulas stay in place longer. Their wet consistency when applied makes them very smooth and easy to apply but as they dry up quickly.

This means that you don’t have to worry about smudging. The best eyeliners for oily lids won’t budge after drying.

As gel eyeliners are available in potted and special pencil varieties, you also have a choice in what you’ll be more comfortable to use.

Powdery formulas are also good options for many because they can blot out your natural oils. Traditional eyeliner pencils usually have such consistency so they’re very easy to find. However, not all of them have long-lasting formulas, so you have to be very particular when opting for such. They can also be quite tricky to use if you’re a big fan of tightlining but they’re great if you love the smeared, smokey look for your eyes.

Liquid formulas are also great options as they tend to offer some of the most long-lasting and highly pigmented options. They offer great results as the pigment makes sure that the product won’t fade away as the day wears on. They’re also often formulated to be as good as the best waterproof eyeliners so you can be guaranteed that they won’t budge easily.

The only downside, even to the best liquid eyeliner for oily lids, is that they can be tricky to apply. A lot of people get intimidated by the wands used to line with these formulas. If you’re one of those who never seem to get the hang of these things, you can always just opt for a pen version. This will let you use these eyeliners like a pencil, offering you great control in its application.

Read the best eyeliners for oily lids reviews.

User and expert reviews will be your best sources of information if a product works or not. These write-ups will let you know the most crucial details about the different products available today without having to actually buy one. They’re perfect for the practical shopper as they will save you from having to spend money to test the product yourself.

When reading reviews, though, make sure to be discerning of the accounts that you’ll believe. Not all of them are true so you need to be very discerning. Look for the products that are reviewed by users with oily skin and eyelids and you might just find the right match for you.

Cast a wide net.

While products made in the USA tend to guarantee great quality, don’t hesitate to widen your search. As any beauty buff knows, there are lots of other great nations that make amazing cosmetics. They can offer the right match for you, so you should check out what they have in store. You might be surprised at how well best eyeliners for oily lids made in Korea perform. European brands tend to have an amazing selection as well, so make sure to give them a shot.

How to Make Your Eyeliner Last Longer

If you really want to find the best results, though, you might also want to do more than just find the best eyeliner for your greasy eyelids. Sometimes, it’s really not just the cosmetic product that has a problem. In some cases, your oily lids make it very difficult for makeup to stay in place. By addressing that issue, you’ll have better odds at finding a great eyeliner that works.

What should you do to better manage the oiliness of your lids? One technique is to be careful in choosing moisturizers or eye creams. If your skincare regimen involves heavy lotions, it might prove to be too much for your eyelids.

This is especially true if you use them right before applying makeup. They can make your skin even oilier, so it’s best to switch to a gentler and lighter moisturizing product for your eyelids.

Using an eyelid primer is also highly recommended for those with oily lids. The best eyeliner primer for oily lids will help eye makeup adhere better to your skin. It can also prevent excessive oil production, so your eye makeup won’t slide off and last longer.

Finally, make sure they can be taken easily with wipes or towelettes so that you don't have to worry about removal after a night out.

We hope you are keeping your make up well-organized so that you don't mix up the eyeliners for oily skin with the regular ones.

Once you need to remove your makeup, there are natural make up removers for oily skin you can use.

Eyeliner for Oily Lids Reviews: Which Products Will Survive Your Oily Lids?

Now that you know what to look for in an eyeliner that will work well with your oily eyelids, you’re all ready to start shopping. For this, here are the best eyeliners for oily lids that might just be the best picks for you:

4.3/5

What better product to start this best eyeliners list than with the Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner? As the name suggests, this product has the “perfect point” so it can promise you great results, no matter what look you might be going for.

Just how perfect is its perfect point, you might be wondering? While it doesn’t offer the thinnest lines, it’s highly versatile. This makes it a great choice for a lot of users who want to change up their looks from time to time.

 It can be used for tightlining, creating cat eyes, and accentuating the waterline as one would expect from a good eyeliner. But as it also comes with a smudge tip, you can also easily use it to create softer lines and smoky, sexy looks.

What makes it a great option for those with oily lids is its long-lasting wear. A lot of users actually say that it’s rather difficult to take off which can both be a good and bad thing. It’s good because it promises that it won’t budge. If you have oily lids, this is exactly what you want in an eyeliner, as mentioned above.

However, because it’s hard to take off, you will need to make an extra effort to make sure that all of the product is removed before you hit the hay. This way, you can be guaranteed not to irritate your eyes and skin.

As a pencil eyeliner, you can expect this product to glide on your skin. This makes it easy to apply but it’s also quite easy to smudge. If you’re after a product to create those sexy, smoky, rocker-chick looks, this can be a great choice. It’s also great for softer lines with the right color choice.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Easy to work with
  • check
    Creates highly versatile looks
  • check
    Lasts all day
  • check
    Self-sharpening

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Takes a while to remove which guarantees its longevity
  • exclamation-triangle
    Smudges quite easily

4.2/5

While it’s pretty common for cosmetic products to have nourishing ingredients in them, they’re not often highlighted in eyeliners. This is why the Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil is a popular choice as it comes with ingredients that are good for the skin. It’s also a great option for those with oily lids since oily skin also needs to be moisturized regularly.

With the addition of olive oil and shea butter, this pencil eyeliner offers to add more than just a few defining lines to your lids. It can also help hydrate, soften, and nourish your skin. Even if it will only cover a small area, it can still contribute to the good health of your skin.

Convenient and easy to use, a lot of people also like that this product has some sparkle to it. This helps it brighten your eyes a little bit, making you look more alert and awake. It’s also quite versatile with its relatively pointy tip and additional smudger.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Formulated with moisturizing ingredients
  • check
    Self-sharpening
  • check
    Has some sparkle
  • check
    Tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists to be safe and suitable for sensitive skin and eyes

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Longevity can be significantly boosted by a layer of primer

4.1/5

If you want to create precise lines and have complete control over your eyeliner, the Mia Adora Best Waterproof Liquid Gel Eyeliner Pen is an option worth checking out. Deemed by some as the best gel eyeliner for oily lids, it promises that it won’t smudge or smear because of your oily eyelids.

Also known as the Tattoo Effect eyeliner, this liquid gel eyeliner pen is a top choice for its ease of use. It’s felt tip doesn’t need sharpening and very easy to wield. And while you can’t really alter the thickness of its tip, it’s still quite versatile. You can just trace your lines to make them thicker so you can achieve the most precise results you aim for. These make it perfect for anyone who doesn’t want a fussy way to apply eye makeup.

It’s a great choice for those with oily lids because of its long-lasting wear. Being a liquid gel eyeliner, it promises to adhere nicely to your skin. It won’t move even when your skin starts to get oily, especially if you wear some primer underneath. It’s high pigmentation also guarantees that it won’t easily fade away, ensuring that it will stay visible all day long.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Gentle and cruelty-free formulation
  • check
    Highly pigmented
  • check
    Waterproof and guaranteed long-lasting wear
  • check
    Very easy to use

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Can dry out when not stored properly
  • exclamation-triangle
    Can get crumbly at the end of the day

4.3/5

A lot of people doubts the longevity of pencil eyeliners, maybe because they’ve been disappointed in one before. The BaeBlue Best Natural Vegan Eyeliner Pencil might just change your mind, though. This long-wearing pencil eyeliner offers a wide range of benefits which is why it deserves a spot in this list.

Aside from its staying power, another major draw this product has is its all-natural, skin-nourishing ingredients. Its key ingredients, jojoba seed oil and castor oil, are both moisturizing, healing, and can help balance your skin’s sebum production. These make it all the more suitable for your oily eyelids.

Its healthy ingredients list doesn’t stop there, though. Without any artificial ingredients, parabens, and fragrance, it can also be a good match for those with sensitive skin. So if your skin often reacts to eyeliners, this product can offer a nice alternative.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Made of all-natural, organic, skin-nourishing ingredients
  • check
    Vegan and cruelty-free formulation
  • check
    Long-lasting wear
  • check
    Available in three beautiful colors

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    A bit pricey for its size

4.1/5

Hailed by many as the best eyeliner for tightlining oily lids, the Docolor Liquid Eyeliner Pen can be everything you need in creating the fiercest wings and cat eyes. This liquid eyeliner pen offers ease of use, great precision, and long-lasting wear so it might just work wonders on your problematic lids.

The first thing that you should know about this product is that it dries up fast. It only takes a second for it to dry up so it can immediately set and adhere to your eyelids. It might be a bit tricky at first, but with some practice, it might just turn out to be a reliable cosmetic product for you. It can be your lifesaver if you’re always strapped for time.

Due to its soft felt tip and continuous flow, you can expect this product to glide smoothly on your lids. It won’t skip so do-overs aren’t required. These also make it ideal for tightlining because you won’t need to keep retracing your lines that can result in thicker lines.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Dries fast for easy, everyday use
  • check
    Very easy to work with
  • check
    Lasts for 12 hours
  • check
    Waterproof formula that’s suitable for sensitive skin

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Not oil proof but will work better with the help of an eyelid primer

4.2/5

K-beauty may have popularized imported skincare and cosmetic products in the recent years but Japanese beauty brands have long been respected and coveted by the pickiest beauty buffs. They tend to combine traditional elements with innovative features that make what they offer impressive.

One good example is the Eve by Eve's Natural Ingredients Smudge Proof Water-resistant Felt-tip Conditioning Liquid Eyeliner. Considered by many as the best eyeliner for oily hooded lids, this liquid eyeliner pen offers exactly what you’d expect from a popular J-beauty product. It combines the sleekness of a calligraphy pen with healthy ingredients, offering a different take on eyeliners.

Glides smoothly, innovative, waterproof, highly-pigmented, and packed with skin-nourishing ingredients, it also takes things up a notch with its posh packaging. Housed in a gold, felt-tip pen, this product is sure to wow.

It also delivers its promises. It’s long-wearing, doesn’t smudge, and is very easy to use. It’s also a wonderful option for greasy eyelids because of its gentle and quick-drying formulation.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Contains skin-nourishing ingredients
  • check
    Elegant packaging
  • check
    Waterproof and long wearing
  • check
    Very easy to work with

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    A bit pricey

4.0/5

Another product that is out to prove wrong those who think that pencil eyeliners don’t last long is the Sigma Beauty Long Wear Black Eyeliner Pencil. It’s not deemed by many as the best pencil eyeliner for oily lids for nothing because this product dries fast despite not having a liquid formula.

While it has a creamy, satin-y texture, this product dries up a few seconds after application. This allows it to stay in place all day long, making it a solid choice for those with oily lids. As it’s also a pencil eyeliner, you can opt to smudge it for a softer, smoky effect but you have to do it fast. It will then stay perfectly in place after.

Created to serve as the perfect companion to Sigma’s cult-favorite eyeshadow range, the Long Wear Eyeliner is also water, fade, and smudge-proof. These will guarantee that it won’t budge all for 8 hours or more.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Mild formula without any phthalates, parabens, sulfates, mineral oils, and casein
  • check
    Satin-y finish with long-lasting wear
  • check
    Popular among beauty gurus and vloggers
  • check
    Friendly price

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Can work better with an eyelid primer if your eyelids are excessively oily

About the Author LYDIA

Popular posts