take a look at some of the best eyeliner pencils

6 Best Eyeliner Pencils of 2018 | For Your Eyes Only

One of the most unfortunate things in life is that not a lot of people recognize the magic eyeliners have. For the uninitiated, even the best eyeliner pencils are just some of the most mundane cosmetic items out there. Some people don’t even get what it’s for so it’s not surprising that it takes a while for them to notice just how much of an impact these products have in one’s look.  

If you’ll pay attention, however, it’s quite easy to see how wearing eyeliner can change up your entire look. Experts call it a transformative product because of this.

It’s also one of the most complex makeup products out there. While it might seem like the easiest thing to apply, it’s also very tricky to master. This makes it all the more interesting as there are just so many dimensions to it.

The only constant thing about eyeliners is that you’ll need one of the best eyeliner pencils one to achieve the results you desire. Finding the best eyeliner is another complicated matter as there are so many different options and things to consider when shopping for these items.

Here are the Best Eyeliner Pencils Reviewed

4.5/5

  • Formulated for sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lens
  • Smooth, velvety texture that’s easy to apply
  • Waterproof, stays in place, and lasts all day

4.2/5

  • Highly versatile
  • Very affordable
  • Creamy consistency and lasts all day

4.4/5

  • Extremely smooth glide offers easy application
  • Six colors available
  • Contains moisturizing ingredient

So if you’re stumped on where to start looking or what to look for in the best eyeliner pencils, make sure to read this guide all the way through. We’re dishing out some of the most useful tips that should help you find the tool you need to make a perfect cat-eye and more.

What to Consider when Choosing One of the Best Eyeliner Pencils

Another mistake a lot of people make is to think that all eyeliners are the same. They might have a very specific purpose but composition-wise, they can’t be more different. They’re available in various types which makes shopping for best eyeliner pencils a tricky task.

Pencil eyeliners tend to be one of the best options because they’re quite easy to use and are highly versatile. They’re not as intimidating as liquid eyeliners so you can get the hang of its use right away. They’re also easy to maneuver since practically everyone is used to wielding a pencil.

Its versatility is also worth noting. You can use it to create the sleekest and sharpest lines with the right techniques. The gel eyeliner pencils can promise long-lasting wear. Regular ones, however, can help you create the sexiest and smokiest eye makeup ever.

The best thing about opting for one of the best eyeliner pencils, however, is that you’ve already narrowed down your options by making this choice. By eliminating liquid eyeliners and potted gel eyeliners from your options, you can now just focus on searching for the best pencils out there.

To help get your search started, here are a few considerations that you should remember when choosing between the best eyeliner pencils to datel.

Your Skin Type

No matter what kind of makeup product you’re after, you always need to consider your skin type. Why? It can determine whether the product will actually work on you. However, when it comes to eyeliner pencils, you have to be extra discerning if you have oily skin.

chose the best eyeliner pencil by your skin type

Most folks with oily skin are also very likely to have oily lids. And as everyone knows, this can prevent your makeup from staying in place. In that case, you'll often need the best makeup remover wipes on hand.

This is true even for eyeliners, so you should look for the ones with staying power. These products are formulated to adhere to your skin so even if you get oily, it won’t easily move. Meantime, check out our best bb creams for oily skin.

Those with sensitive skin also has to be extra careful in purchasing an eyeliner. You can’t just look for the best eyeliner pencil that doesn’t smudge. You also have to be particular with the formulation of the product.

Why? Because even if this product will only cover a small area of your skin, it can still be seriously irritating. Combined with the fact that the skin around your eyes is thin and fragile, your eyelids can be easily damaged if you’re not careful.

The wrong eyeliner can cause swelling, itchiness, and even dermatitis. These make it ideal to be extra cautious if you have skin sensitivities.

Your Local Climate and Your Usual Activities

One of the issues a lot of people raise about eyeliner pencils is that they don’t usually last all day. This is especially true if you live in a warm region or if you have an active lifestyle. Heat and sweat can cause this makeup to melt and disappear by mid-day and it’s such a hassle to constantly touch up your makeup.

This is another reason why you should look for a product with excellent staying power. This usually prompts people to look for the ​best waterproof eyeliner and it’s a wise idea. Gel eyeliner pencils can also be great options for such instances.

The Look You Want to Achieve

As mentioned above, pencil eyeliners are very versatile. However, there are still different kinds with their own specific purposes.

For example, the best gel eyeliner pencil can offer clean, sharp lines that will last all day long. Lots of people find them easier to use since you don’t have to deal with a small, pointy brush anymore.

On the other hand, you can find some of the best eyeliner pencils for waterline among the regular pencil eyeliners. Their softer output makes them ideal for this area. They’re also easier to blend and can even be smudged intentionally for certain looks. Perfect for everyday wear, these products are often considered as must-haves.

Your Eye Color

The best eyeliner pencils come in a very wide range of hues and shades. Not all of them will look great on you, though. Some will intensify your eye color, so they can be better options for you.

To help you choose, here are some color matches that experts recommend:

  • For blue eyes: copper, gold, navy, champagne, and terra-cotta.
  • For green eyes: bronze, garnet, amethyst, rust, mahogany, aubergine, and other colors with reddish undertones.
  • For brown eyes: earthy browns, amber, midnight blue, cobalt, mink grey, and purple.
  • For hazel eyes: gold, emerald, bronze, plum, and olive.

The Best Eyeliner Pencils Reviews

Ready to start shopping? These eyeliner pencil reviews can help point you in the right direction.

4.5/5

For something that doesn’t budge, the Maybelline Makeup Unstoppable Smudge-Proof Eyeliner is a solid choice. As its name suggests, nothing can stop this product from lasting all day long. Not the heat, your sweat, or oily lids. This makes it the best waterproof eyeliner pencil out there.

Like the Perfect Point, the Unstoppable Smudge-Proof Eyeliner also comes with a liquid-like consistency. It’s velvety and rich in texture so it glides into the skin with ease. However, it also dries up quite quickly. So if you want to blend it out to achieve a softer look, you have to do it fast.

While this can make it a bit tricky to apply, it also guarantees that it won’t budge after its application. This is a solid guarantee that it can then last the whole day, no matter what activity you may have in store or what season it is.

Aside from its long-lasting wear, it’s also notable for its gentle formula. It’s ophthalmologist- tested, so you can be guaranteed that it won’t pose risks to your eyes. It’s also made safe for use by those who wear contact lens, so you’re assured that it won’t irritate and injure your peepers.

Available in 5 neutral colors, it’s quite easy to choose from its selection. Every color will suit nearly everyone so you can’t go wrong with what they offer. However, folks who are after bolder and more vibrant options might need to look elsewhere.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Formulated for sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lens
  • check
    Smooth, velvety texture that’s easy to apply
  • check
    Waterproof, stays in place, and lasts all day
  • check
    Highly versatile and capable of creating different looks

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Additional bright color options to the 5 available neutral ones would be nice

4.2/5

For our first eyeliner pencil review, we’ll look at the widely popular Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner. This product appeals to those who prefer the ease of handling a pencil but with a longer-lasting wear and convenience of the more modern varieties of eyeliner products.

The first thing that makes it very convenient to use is its mechanical style. You don’t need to use a sharpener to get to the product making it fuss-free. It just won’t get as pointy as some would like to let them create the sharpest and thinnest lines.

This is actually where it got its name because it offers the perfect point for various looks. It’s versatile enough for everyday casual looks but you can also easily create something softer with it. As it’s also equipped with a blending tip, you can blend in the lines you’ve created and achieve a different look.

The usual creamy consistency used in most of the best eyeliner pencils is also improved in this product. It’s formulated to be smooth and liquid-like so it glides in during application. It’s also long lasting so you don’t have to worry about having to retouch your eye makeup frequently.

Available in 7 different colors, you can also be sure to find something that will bring out your eyes.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Highly versatile
  • check
    Very affordable
  • check
    Creamy consistency and lasts all day
  • check
    Self-sharpening design makes it more efficient

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Smudges easily which makes it perfect for softer looks and easy to blend in
  • exclamation-triangle
    You can’t really make the tip very pointy which is what lot of users prefer

4.4/5

If your idea of the best pencil eyeliner is something that’s also good for your skin, then the Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil would be a great pick for you. Not only does this item contain good ingredients but it’s also tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists. These guarantee that its use won’t irritate or damage your eyelids.

Infused with olive oil and shea butter, it promises to effectively moisturize and nourish your skin. This tends to offer better results, since it won’t just enhance your appearance but will also improve the quality of your skin as well.

These additional ingredients can also explain why this product has a really smooth texture. It will glide on your skin, making application very easy. And with the help of the blending tip, it’s also easy to create softer looks with its consistency.

If you’re worried about its staying power, don’t be. It can promise long-lasting results so there’s a good chance that you won’t need to re-apply in the middle of the day.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Extremely smooth glide offers easy application
  • check
    Six colors available
  • check
    Contains moisturizing ingredients

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Choosing a color can be a bit tricky

4.5/5

Another option for an eyeliner pencil that will let you create ultra-fine lines to thick lines is the Maybelline Makeup Unstoppable Smudge-Proof Eyeliner, Espresso Edition. This can be a bit surprising for many since it’s a self-sharpening eyeliner, but thanks to its special design, it gets to offer versatility.

What allows this product to create both thin and thick lines is the swiveling action of its mechanical part. The action, combined with the shape of the eyeliner housing, keeps its tip sharp. This makes it versatile as it will let you create different looks without a fuss.

Why is it called “Unstoppable”? It’s because nothing can stop it from performing all-day. It’s formulated to last long so you can expect it to stay in place and not budge for anything. It’s waterproof, run-proof, and smudge-proof, so nothing can get in its way to keep it from giving you the look you want to achieve.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Capable of creating various looks
  • check
    Tip stays pointed despite its mechanical pencil style
  • check
    Long-lasting and smudge-proof
  • check
    Safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Needs to be blended in immediately if you want a softer look as it dries fast

4.1/5

While self-sharpening pencil eyeliners are great and efficient, some folks need pointed tips to create thin and precise lines. This is why the traditional Mia Adora Best Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Sharpener is also a great choice for many. 

Because it’s an actual pencil, you can sharpen it to create ultra-fine lines or just leave it be for thicker lines. This makes it highly versatile, allowing you to try different looks with just one product.

As the name will also tell you, this product stays right where you put it. Its waterproof and run-proof so you don’t have to worry about your sweat, tears, the heat, and humidity ruining your look.

But what really makes this product stand out is its ability to work on the waterline. Other pencil eyeliners won’t even show up in your waterline. So the fact that this Mia Adora eyeliner works well for this area and even stays in place for a long while makes it an even more worthy choice.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Can create thin, sharp, and very fine lines
  • check
    Comes with a removable pencil sharpener
  • check
    Waterproof, smudge-proof, and long lasting

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Only has one color available but as it’s versatile, it’s still a great choice

4.3/5

Thanks to its all-natural composition, the BaeBlue Best Natural Vegan Eyeliner Pencil can be a great option for those with diet restrictions and strict preferences in what goes into their skin.

As the name suggests it’s a vegan eyeliner so it’s safe to assume that it’s made completely of plant-based products. Because of this, you can be assured that it only uses plant-based ingredients that are also nourishing for your skin.

Its key ingredients? Jojoba and castor oils. Jojoba oil moisturizes while the castor oil heals the skin and fights signs of aging. Even though this product won’t cover a lot of skin, it’s still better to use something with nourishing ingredients than toxic ones so it’s not surprising that it’s a popular pick.

Despite using all-natural ingredients, it’s still capable of delivering great results. It glides smoothly on the skin for easy application and lasts all day long. It’s also great for soft, subtle, and casual looks, so it can be one of the best eyeliner pencils for everyone.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Vegan and cruelty-free
  • check
    No fragrance, parabens, preservatives, artificial colors, and harmful chemicals
  • check
    Easy to use

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Some think that it has a limited color range (only 2 colors available)

Here's a cool tutorial about mistakes to avoid when using best eyeliner pencils: 

Share a comment on the best eyeliner pencils you've used so far!

About the Author LYDIA

Popular posts