Best Eyebrow Mascaras

The 5 Best Eyebrow Mascaras to Achieve the Lushest, Boldest Brows of Your Life

The makeup scene has always been expanding and introducing new techniques to enhance one’s features. This is why it shouldn’t be too surprising that when bold, defined brows became the trend, new products were also released. The best eyebrow mascaras got popular and in high demand even if not everyone understands what exactly it is yet.

Also known as eyebrow gels, these beauty products are some of the latest must-haves if you’ve jumped on the bold eyebrow trend. They promise to help you get the lushest brows ever with just a few expert swipes.

Interested in adding one or two to your makeup collection? Here’s what you need to know about these products and a few item suggestions that you might find useful.

Our Top Rated Eyebrow Mascara to Look Your Best

  • arrow-right
    Flexible precise felt tip helps to create thin, thick or winged lines, creating a multitude of looks easily
  • arrow-right
    Quick-dry intensely dark black ink with no smudges, feathering, or running
  • arrow-right
    Water-proof for long wear times

Best Eyebrow Mascaras on the Market

Product
Water Resistant Levels
Our Rating
Ucanbe Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Pen Long Lasting Eyeliner



Waterproof
5.0
Mommy Makeup Brow Tint



Water-resistant
4.5
Maybelline New York Volume' Express The Rocket Waterproof Mascara



Waterproof
4.5
Beauty Junkees Clear Brow Gel



Not waterproof
4.5
OxygenBeauty Eyebrow Gel



Waterproof
4.0

Buying Guide: What’s an Eyebrow Mascara and How Do You Find One that Suits Your Needs?

Even those who keep themselves updated with the latest beauty trends might still need a hand to get to know the new products that can up their beauty game. If you’re curious about eyebrow mascaras, here are the basics that you should know.

What is an Eyebrow Mascara?

As the name suggests, an eyebrow mascara is a mascara for your brows. It can have the same creamy consistency as your favorite lash mascara and is uses the same concept, except you apply this product on your brows.

Again, like las mascaras, they brow gels can add color and volume to your brows. By doing so, it can make your brows appear thicker and bolder. These can also help you better define your brows and get them “on fleek”.

Eyebrow gels also come in clear and tinted varieties like lash mascaras. They’re also available in various formulations and shades so you can definitely go for the look and feel you want.

The Marvels of the Eyebrow Mascara

Why should you try out the best eyebrow gel? Here are a few reasons what makes them worth a shot:

1. It gives your brows a polished look.

Most people use mascara to hold their lashes in place. And since brow and lash mascaras share the same design, it’s safe to say that you can also turn to these items if you have unruly brows. If yours tend to stick to various directions that makes you look like you’ve been constantly rubbing your brows, brow mascaras can work for you.

If you already have bushy brows and don’t want to make it look thicker, clear brow mascaras will be great picks for you. Like clear lash mascaras, the best clear eyebrow gels will keep your brows in place without altering its look.

2. It’s a lazy girl must-have.

Doing your brows, especially if you need to add volume to it, can be a tedious task. Penciling it in can take a while. Brow gels, however, can make it appear thicker by adhering to the hair strands so it can be easier to work with. Many makeup junkies who are self-professed lazies love these products because of the convenience they offer.

3. It’s great for those hot and humid days.

If you have a problem with makeup melting or disappearing on you on hot and humid days, these items can prove to be the best eyebrow makeup for you. The gel consistency of these products won’t easily budge and won’t wash off when you sweat or get oily. So you can swap your old brow pencil with these mascaras during the summer.

Choosing the Right Eyebrow Mascara for You

Like when shopping for other cosmetic products, choosing the best eyebrow mascara for you depends largely on your preferences and needs. Here are three of the most basic and general rules that can help you narrow down your options, though.

1. The wand makes a huge difference.

Also known as spoolies, mascara wands come in different shapes and configurations. Each promise to have a different effect on your look. This is why you might want to consider this detail when shopping for an eyebrow mascara.

2. Pick a color that works for you.

Just like when shopping for the best eyebrow pencil, the shade of your brow gel will also make or break your look. There are tons of expert tips for this, so you shouldn’t worry about not knowing where to start.

3. Find out what a product is like when it dries up.

Is it crunchy? Does it get clumpy? If the answer is yes to any or both questions, avoid the product like the plague. You want your eyebrows to look naturally lush and thick so you shouldn’t risk it cracking and weighed down.

Reading eyebrow mascara reviews will help you get to know about these details, so make sure to do so. It will definitely save you from wasting money on a product that doesn’t work.

Our Top 5 Eyebrow Mascara Reviews

Here are the eyebrow mascara reviews of our top 5 picks so you can get begin your search in the right direction.

You must be wondering why the Ucanbe Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner Pen Long Lasting Eyeliner is on a best eyebrow mascara list when it’s clearly labeled as an eyeliner. Well, the answer is very simple: this is a double duty product. This makes it a good pick in our books.

Designed to help you create the sharpest cat eyes and most precise wings, this eyeliner promises to go on smoothly, color evenly, and last a long while. When you put it on, you can expect it to stay on until it’s time to take it off. It’s also very easy to work with, so you can be sure that it can help you pull off polished looks without a struggle.

What makes it even better is the fact that it works as a brow gel as well. This offers more value for your money which is always a great thing.

Due to its gel consistency, it can easily add a good amount of volume to your brows more easily. You can also expect it to last longer than eyebrow pencils which makes it suitable for busy days. Application of this product, however, is a lot like how you’d use eyebrow pencils so it can still be rather tricky.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Works as an eyeliner and brow gel
  • check
    Waterproof and long-lasting
  • check
    Glides smoothly
  • check
    Highly pigmented
  • check
    Doesn't smudge, feature, or run as it dries quickly

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Still works like a brow pencil so it can be trickier to master
  • exclamation-triangle
    List Element
  • exclamation-triangle
    List Element

Those who love their skin but also love getting their glam on should check out the Mommy Makeup Brow Tint. This is one of the few cosmetic products on the market that doesn’t have paraben in it so you don’t have to worry about your skin absorbing a lot of unwanted chemicals.

Parabens are common preservatives in cosmetic products so you can find them almost everywhere. However, there’s some evidence that it can be bad for your health. There are signs that they can cause breast tumors which makes them quite dangerous. Because of this, paraben-free products are thought of as safer alternatives.

Aside from eliminating the threats of cancer, the Mommy Makeup Brow Tint is also a popular choice for its performance. It’s waterproof and long-lasting so you can wear it all day without worrying about having missing eyebrows by the end of the day.

It also looks rather natural as it adds volume to your hair strands instead of drawing lines on the skin underneath the brows. It has a clump-free formula and doesn’t have a plastic sheen to it, making it a nice pick for ladies with sparse and thin brows.

Available in four shades (Blonde, Fawn, Auburn, and Sable), Mommy Makeup is also a cruelty-free brand. So if you don’t want to use products that have treated animals poorly, this brow tint is worth checking out.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Available in four different shades
  • check
    Looks natural
  • check
    Clump-free formula
  • check
    Paraben and cruelty free

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    A bit more expensive than the other products on this list

Here’s another product that can double duty as a brow mascara: the Maybelline New York Volume' Express The Rocket Waterproof Mascara. With Maybelline being one of the most popular drugstore brands for the best lash mascaras, many might be wondering whether some of their items can work on the brows as well. Since both lashes and brows have hair on them, why not, right?

Apparently, you can use this product as a brow mascara as well. All you need is a clean spoolie to blend and remove the excess product out, a light hand for application, and that’s pretty much it.

As the name suggests, this Volum’ Express variant offers “explosive” volume. It will give your lashes great volume that will stay on. It’s very waterproof that some folks cried while wearing it without ending up looking like a streaky raccoon. While this also means that it will be hard to take off, there are always those heavy duty makeup removers in the form of cleansing oils and micellar water that will get the job done.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Works wonders as a lash mascara
  • check
    Seriously long lasting and waterproof
  • check
    Will add lots of volume with just a few swipes
  • check
    Dense wand offers efficient application

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Can be hard to remove which is also a good thing if you need a heavy-duty mascara

If you already have bushy brows and don’t want to add volume to it anymore, the Beauty Junkees Clear Brow Gel is an option that you should consider. This clear mascara works like a setting product for your bold brows.

The main purpose of this product is that it can help your brows to stay put all day long and give you a polished look. It dries matte so you don’t have to worry about having an unnatural appearance when wearing this product.

Those with thinner brows can also layer it with other eyebrow products to achieve a fuller look. It won’t dry stiffly but it will hold your brows in place, so it can still be a good choice even if you prefer using gel products on your brows.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Paraben-free
  • check
    Also available in tinted varieties
  • check
    Lasts all day long as long as you do not get it wet
  • check
    Very easy to apply

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Not waterproof
  • exclamation-triangle
    List Element
  • exclamation-triangle
    List Element

Are your brows in need of more than just filling in? The OxygenBeauty Eyebrow Gel might just be the perfect fit for you. Deemed as one of the top rated eyebrow mascaras in the market today, this product is also designed to add great volume, define, and add great volume to your brows.

What makes this product different is its overall design. The packaging alone makes it stand out. While it uses the same tube and wand design like other mascara products, its wand stands out because of its paddle shape. So instead of using spoolies, it has a paddle applicator that can also cover a specific amount of surface area. This makes it easier to shape your brows and make it thicker than it really is in a single swipe.

As for the product itself, it’s rather thick and creamy. It’s formulated to be waterproof and smudge proof so it can withstand sweating and even a swim. These guarantee that it can last all day so you don’t have to worry about your brows disappearing after an intense physical activity. Natural-looking and highly pigmented, this brow tint can go a long way.

Things We Liked

  • check
    Unique paddle-shaped wand can easily thicken thin brows
  • check
    Smudge and waterproof
  • check
    Anti-sweat long-lasting formula
  • check
    Doesn't flake and natural-looking

Things We Didn't Like

  • exclamation-triangle
    Shades have darker t ints
  • exclamation-triangle
    You might need to get used to the wand for the most precise application

About the Author Samantha Brown

Growing up as a kid who played outside, Samantha enjoys an active lifestyle and emphasizes health as a key component to her life. She enjoys sharing her knowledge with others so that anybody can live a healthy life. On the weekends, you can find her hiking around Southern California!

Popular posts