Last Updated on
We’ve carefully researched some of the most important qualities of a good product and compiled extensive reviews to help you decide on the best drugstore eyebrow pencil for you.
Great eyebrows don’t always come naturally. Plenty of thought and effort go into all of the perfect brows that are being arched at you from advertisements and tv screens. For many, an essential to eyebrow cultivation is a good eyebrow pencil. And just like eyebrows, not all eyebrow pencils are created equally. Here are our recommended products!
[OVERALL BEST EYEBROW PENCIL]
[BEST FOR THE MONEY]
[Best Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil]
So, what should you look for when buying an eyebrow pencil? If the eyes are the window to the soul, we could compare eyebrows to window boxes, curtains, and eves. Amazing eyebrows are capable of adding eons of symmetry, power and intrigue to your expressions.
If we’re honest, however, few of us are born with amazing eyebrows. Plucking, grooming and coloring are all a part of turning average eyebrows into the statements we want them to be. The importance of eyebrow pencils cannot be overstated.
Here are a few things you may wonder as you prepare to purchase an eyebrow pencil.
Brow pencils and powder are actually often used in combination with one another. If you have sparse or empty areas in your brow, brow powder can help fill them in.
It generally has a less definite look than a brow pencil. Brow powder can also be used to set a look achieved using a brow pencil.
For even bolder eyebrow definition, you may want to check into more recently popular products such as mascara for eyebrows.
The most popular choice, for those choosing between powder or a pencil, is the pencil. With short, light strokes, you can use an eyebrow pencil to fill in gaps as well as define the shape of your eyebrow in a way that looks natural and right.
A great way to choose an eyebrow pencil is to start where you’re starting now. Read reviews of different pencils and compare their assets with your needs.
Think about whether you want a pencil that is waterproof, how fine a tip it will need to have, and what color would go best with your natural eyebrow.
Some pencils are also designed to work well with other cosmetics, such as eyebrow powder. And of course, you’ll want to find a high-quality pencil that also fits your budget. Below, you’ll find seven eyebrow pencil reviews covering some of these specialties, including our top picks in waterproof and budget-friendly eyebrow pencils.
Our top-rated eyebrow pencil is the Anastasia Beverly Hills - Brow Wiz – Granite pencil. Another pencil that is especially good for filling in sparse brows is our best budget pick, the Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Pencil. This pencil has a teardrop tip, which makes for faster filling.
Also be sure to choose a pencil with a spoolie tip you can use to blend your strokes for a soft, natural look. If your eyebrows need a bit of extra help, you may want to consider combining the use of an eyebrow pencil and eyebrow powder to really build them up in a way that looks natural and beautiful.
If you’re interested in actually thickening your eyebrows, you may also want to check out our review for some of the best serums for eyebrow growth.
One of the most important things to take into consideration when choosing an eyebrow pencil is the natural color of your eyebrows. The best practice is to choose a color that is actually a shade lighter than your natural brows. This ensures that your added strokes blend in rather than standing out.
For blonde brows, a pencil with a warm undertone is a good choice, as this will bring out your color without contrasting it. For darker brows, you can go with a light brunette, and even black brows can be filled in and shaped with a dark brunette pencil.
Now that you have a better idea of what you’re looking for, here are our reviews for seven of the best eyebrow pencils you’ll find in drugstores.
The Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz includes all the best features of a great eyebrow pencil. The granite color is a cool shade, perfect for matching true black hair. A dark charcoal, it also works well with dark brown hair, adding a rich, defined strength to your brows.
This pencil offers long-lasting color that is simply applied. Although it’s not a waterproof pencil, with average activity, you won’t have to worry about it smudging or wearing off during the day. The fine tip lays color on smoothly and easily.
Once you have defined the shape of your brow and filled in any sparse areas, you can use the spoolie on the end of the pencil to lightly blend your strokes for a perfect, natural look.
For a more budget-friendly pencil, our top pick is the Maybelline New York Total Temptation Eyebrow Pencil. This pencil has a teardrop tip that is perfect for shaping your brows and achieving a natural but defined look.
The thicker tip of this pencil is also great for filling in sparse brows for a full, smooth look.
With its soft color and ease of application, you may be surprised to discover that this is also a solid, long lasting eyebrow pencil.
It can be difficult to find an eyebrow pencil shade that is exactly right for your natural eyebrow color. This pencil works for quite a few complexions and seems to go especially well with hair color that has an auburn undertone.
If you’re an active wearer, looking for a good waterproof eyebrow pencil, L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer pencil may be the best choice for you. This pencil has an ultra-fine tip for defining your brows and using light strokes to fill them out into your desired shape.
The color is waterproof and safe for sensitive skin. Several shades are available to match ashy blonde, dark blonde or cool brunette complexions. The color goes on smoothly and lasts all day! This pencil has a better spoolie than many, which comes in handy for blending everything into a soft, natural texture.
Even if you have thick eyebrows, you can use this pencil to give them a more defined, polish look. Easy application takes just minutes, and then you won’t have to think about it for the rest of the day.
For a careful, precise look, the NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil is a solid and affordable choice.
This product has a great consistency that goes on easily and may be sculpted into a smooth dramatic look or blended for a more natural texture.
With this fine-tipped brow pencil, you can shape your brows however you like for a clean, well-defined arch. It also comes with an attached spoolie, which is super convenient.
You can toss it in your purse for a trip and know you’ll have exactly what you need to keep your brows wowing wherever you end up.
For a full, natural look, ETUDE HOUSE Drawing Eye Brow 0.25g is a smart choice as a regular eyebrow pencil. This pencil has a teardrop tip that will help you achieve a soft, solid shade. You can use the flat side of the tip to lightly trace your brow, or apply the narrow tip in short strokes. Pressing harder will give you a darker color.
The pencil comes with a built-in spoolie with a cap on one end, so you have everything you need to groom your eyebrows to perfection.
With it’s clear, natural look, the Etude House Brow will win over even an eyebrow pencil skeptic (they are out there!). It is a solid go-to pencil for beginners and long-time users alike.
The Chella Eyebrow Pencil stands out as superior yet affordable beauty product. You can use either the fine tip or brush attachment to trace and darken your brows before blending or lightly smudging for a smooth, natural look.
This pencil has a velvety consistency that slips on easily and makes you feel like your pampering your brows.
It’s easy to use and correct but doesn’t smear or fade throughout the day. This is a great pencil for creating exactly the brow you want and still have it look real.
Finally, we can’t not mention that this product is vegan and cruelty-free! You can feel good about using it, which will only add to the enjoyment of looking amazing when you use it.
Our final pick for the best eyebrow pencils available in your drugstore, is the Skone Totally Defined Waterproof Eyebrow Wand.
As the name suggests, this is another waterproof pencil, which makes it perfect for those days when you’re likely to be sweating a lot or maybe getting rained on!
When used correctly, this brow pencil gives you a lovely smooth yet natural look.
Its unique retractable tip is slightly longer than a regular eyebrow pencil, so you have plenty of room to work on details. The pencil also includes a built in spoolie for blending your brow to a smooth finish.
I developed a love for the outdoors, particularly enjoying gloomy days spent in the forests. Almost every Sunday, my dad would drive my mom, myself, and my older sister to go hiking for family time and escaping the "city" life. Because of this, you'll find me writing a lot about various health topics.Whenever I get the opportunity I also love to write about make-up, skin, and hair! I've been obsessed with it ever since middle school so be sure to check out these topics that I write about as well.